logo
Font Size: A | A

Health Insurance Reform

As the health insurance reform debate heats up in Washington and around the country, opponents of end-of-life choice have launched a mis-information campaign to undermine a key provision of health care reform. Recent action and statements indicate the end-of-life consultation provision may survive in a final health care bill.

On October 29th, 2009, Congressman Earl Blumenauer of Oregon stood with leaders of the House of Representatives as they unveiled H.R. 3962, the bill that will be considered on the floor by the House. This bill includes the provision for advance care planning that Blumenauer authored. Read Blumenauer's statement here.

Senator Jay Rockefeller champions end-of-life care in his in his report to the Senate Finance Committee's health care reform legislation:
Advance Care Planning. The Committee mark is silent on advance care planning. As I have asserted throughout this debate, a critical component of a modernized health system is the ability to address the health care needs of patients across the life-span – especially at the end of life. Death is a serious, personal, and complicated part of the life cycle, and care at the end of life is eventually relevant to everyone. Americans deserve end-of-life care that is effective in providing information about diagnosis and prognosis, integrating appropriate support services, fulfilling individual wishes, and avoiding unnecessary disputes.

Read the rest here.

House Resolution 3200, Section 1233 would allow doctors to bill medicare for end-of-life conversation.          

Click here to read House Resolution 3200  (scroll down to section 1233

 

Click here to visit our Action Network: Contact your member of Congress!

Click here to read the myths vs facts on the end-of-life conversation in the health care reform debate.
Click here to read Factcheck.org: False Euthanasia Claims.
Click here to read Politifact: Betsy McCaughy's false claims on end-of-life counseling for Medicare patients.
Serious illness, death and dying are often difficult subjects to talk about. However, a lack of communication among individuals, families and health care professionals on these matters often leads to distress for both patients and their families.

In addition, patients who report having end-of-life conversations with their physicians had significantly lower health care costs in their final week of life.  When care is patient-centered rather than profit centered, patients and their families reap the benefits.
Read the 2009 study in the Archives on Internal Medicine: Health Care Costs in the Last Week of Life.

Read: End-Of-Life Talks Better for Patients and Budgets fromOncology Nursing News.

Read: A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association concluding that end-of-life conversations are associated with less aggressive medical care near death and earlier hospice referrals.
As Congress debates health insurance reform, Compassion & Choices is working to make end-of-life choice a centerpiece of any program that emerges.

We are working hard to reach our goal to make end-of-life choice a centerpiece of national health insurance reform.  The technical term for our goal is “Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment” (POLST).  In practical terms, it’s a new requirement for Medicare to provide coverage for the “conversation” – the dialog between doctor and patient about a patient’s wishes and options for end-of-life treatment.

POLST is one way to get these conversations started. POLST forms allow patients to document with their physician their end-of-life treatment wishes. A decade of research has demonstrated that orders for life-sustaining treatment effectively convey treatment preferences and guide medical personnel to provide or withhold interventions.  These orders contain the individual’s treatment decisions, signed by a physician, and follow the patient through all end-of-life health care settings.  Without these medical orders, emergency medical personnel may be required to provide treatments that aren’t consistent with the individual’s preferences.

Right now, Medicare does not cover this pivotal conversation.  As a result, most doctors don’t suggest it.  And most elderly patients don’t get the opportunity to talk about their questions, values and decisions about the kind of care they want at life’s end.

Winning Medicare coverage to fund the discussion will be transformational.  It will lay the groundwork for coverage in the other plans that will be part of health care reform, secure a valuable right for every American, and keep millions of people from being trapped in agonizing and futile medical interventions in their final weeks of life.

HR 1898, the Life Sustaining Treatment Preferences Act of 2009, introduced by Congressman Earl Blumenauer (D-OR) and Charles Boustany (R-LA), would provide coverage under the Medicare Program for consultations regarding POLST.
Read the Life Sustaining Treatment Preferences Act of 2009.  
Read Compassion & Choices testimony to the Senate Finance Committee.
HR 1898 will lay the groundwork so all seriously ill Americans have the tools to make informed medical care decisions. The bill will also help patients convey their care plans as clearly as possible and feel confident their wishes will be known and respected by health care personnel. These tools will help the dying choose between acute care and hospice care, avoid unwanted medical interventions and do a much better job of explaining why and when to choose hospice care.

To learn more about this and other important bills we are currently working on, read our End-of-Life Legislative Tracking 111th Congress Summary here.


Speak to a Counselor

CARE : QUICK LINKS

 

 

 

 

 

RESOURCES

Living Will Download your state's advance directives
LEARN MORE »
Hospice Tips for funding and using your local hospice
LEARN MORE »
Glossary A glossary of common terms and phrases
LEARN MORE »
Links Links to other organizations and resources
LEARN MORE »
Bookstore Recommended Publications
LEARN MORE »

 

Video

 

BOOKSTORE

Talking About Death
by Virginia Morris

Retail Price: $14.95
Members' Price: $12.50

MORE BOOKS »